Track record
Everything we test, as it came out.
Each row is one test on our own record. We publish all of them: the ones that are proven and the ones that are not.
NIFTY 50 · 26 testsF&O stocks · 3 testsNIFTY 500 · 30 tests
The sets are kept apart: they were run on different companies, and a result proven on one is not claimed for the other.
26 tests listed · 5 proven. Proven = held up in 8 or more separate periods and very unlikely to be luck. More bars, stronger evidence. How we test
NIFTY 50 tests
| What was compared | Kind | Over | Return gap | Evidence | Periods | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Profit beat its usual and the share rose vs the opposite | Results | next month | +1.46 % | 21 | Promising | |
| Profit beat the company's usual vs missed it | Results | next month | -0.75 % | 24 | Not proven | |
| Revenue beat the company's usual vs missed it | Results | next month | +0.45 % | 23 | Not proven | |
| Shares that rose on results day vs those that fell | Results | next month | +0.86 % | 34 | Promising | |
| Profit beat its usual and the share rose vs the opposite | Results | next 3 months | +3.07 % | 20 | Promising | |
| Profit beat the company's usual vs missed it | Results | next 3 months | -1.75 % | 23 | Not proven | |
| Revenue beat the company's usual vs missed it | Results | next 3 months | -0.40 % | 23 | Not proven | |
| Shares that rose on results day vs those that fell | Results | next 3 months | +1.99 % | 33 | Proven | |
| Highest sector score vs lowest | Sectors | next 6 months | +1.57 % | 22 | Not proven | |
| Sectors cheapest against their own 5 years vs dearest | Sectors | next 6 months | -1.72 % | 22 | Not proven | |
| Sectors furthest above their 200-day average vs furthest below | Sectors | next 6 months | +0.31 % | 22 | Not proven | |
| Sectors that rose most over the year vs least | Sectors | next 6 months | +1.35 % | 22 | Not proven | |
| Sectors with the fastest earnings growth vs the slowest | Sectors | next 6 months | -1.12 % | 22 | Not proven | |
| Highest sector score vs lowest | Sectors | next 12 months | -3.80 % | 12 | Not proven | |
| Sectors cheapest against their own 5 years vs dearest | Sectors | next 12 months | +7.05 % | 11 | Promising | |
| Sectors furthest above their 200-day average vs furthest below | Sectors | next 12 months | +2.89 % | 12 | Not proven | |
| Sectors that rose most over the year vs least | Sectors | next 12 months | +2.12 % | 12 | Not proven | |
| Sectors with the fastest earnings growth vs the slowest | Sectors | next 12 months | -6.28 % | 12 | Not proven | |
| Highest short-term score vs lowest | Shares, short term | next month | +1.15 % | 170 | Proven | |
| Shares that did best around their last results vs worst | Shares, short term | next month | +0.83 % | 66 | Proven | |
| Shares that fell hardest lately (lowest RSI) vs the strongest | Shares, short term | next month | +1.22 % | 170 | Proven | |
| Shares with the weakest last month vs the strongest | Shares, short term | next month | +0.60 % | 170 | Promising | |
| Highest short-term score vs lowest | Shares, short term | next 3 months | +0.57 % | 70 | Not proven | |
| Shares that did best around their last results vs worst | Shares, short term | next 3 months | +1.55 % | 27 | Proven | |
| Shares that fell hardest lately (lowest RSI) vs the strongest | Shares, short term | next 3 months | +0.77 % | 70 | Not proven | |
| Shares with the weakest last month vs the strongest | Shares, short term | next 3 months | -0.57 % | 70 | Not proven |
Chance of a fall: what we said against what happened
The figures, with the number of cases
| For | Period | Fall of | Chance we gave | How often it happened | Cases |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nifty | next week | 5 % or more | 4.4 % | 3.2 % | 249 |
| Nifty | next week | 10 % or more | 0.9 % | 0.4 % | 249 |
| Nifty | next month | 5 % or more | 13.1 % | 12.5 % | 170 |
| Nifty | next month | 10 % or more | 5.0 % | 3.2 % | 170 |
| Stock | next week | 5 % or more | 11.1 % | 10.3 % | 249 |
| Stock | next week | 10 % or more | 3.1 % | 2.1 % | 249 |
| Stock | next month | 5 % or more | 23.0 % | 23.6 % | 170 |
| Stock | next month | 10 % or more | 11.5 % | 10.5 % | 170 |
Long outlook: how the 1, 3 and 5-year outlooks did so far
| For | Years ahead | Separate periods | Direction right | Ended inside the 8-in-10 range | What the record can say |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Shares | 1 | 5 | 68 % | 86 % | Too few cases |
| Shares | 3 | 1 | 82 % | 91 % | Too few cases |
| Shares | 5 | 1 | 76 % | 91 % | Too few cases |
| Indices | 1 | 9 | 67 % | 76 % | Not proven |
| Indices | 3 | 3 | 77 % | 80 % | Too few cases |
| Indices | 5 | 2 | 66 % | 59 % | Too few cases |
Company figures start in 2018, so few long periods have passed. Where the record is short we say so rather than claim a result.
Quality checklist
Companies passing the most checks (top fifth) against those passing the fewest (bottom fifth), over the next 12 months: -12.7 %, evidence Too few cases, over 37 months.
F&O stocks: option signals
3 tests · 0 proven. Does a high reading go with a better share return over the next month, across every F&O stock? The direction of each signal was fixed before the data was read.
| Signal | Months | Best fifth vs worst fifth, a month | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Low IV rank (calm options) | 18 | -0.40 % | Not proven |
| Futures OI rose with the price over the month (long build-up) | 23 | -0.56 % | Not proven |
| More puts than calls open (read as a contrarian sign) | 24 | +0.36 % | Promising |
Details for the statistically minded
| Signal | Rank correlation, a month |
|---|---|
| Low IV rank (calm options) | +0.017 |
| Futures OI rose with the price over the month (long build-up) | -0.002 |
| More puts than calls open (read as a contrarian sign) | +0.029 |
Each month the signal is set against the next 21 trading days' return across the stocks, as a rank correlation.
Option history for F&O stocks outside the NIFTY 50 starts two years back, so these tests cover about 24 months; under 12 months is too few to judge. The list is today's F&O stocks, so stocks that left it are not counted.
NIFTY 500: the factors, the risk order and the technical signals
30 tests · 6 proven. The history is today's NIFTY 500, so companies that left it or failed are not counted.
Factors behind the NIFTY 500 rank
| Factor | Up to 2020 | From 2021 | All months | Used |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12-month momentum return from 12 months to 1 month ago | Proven | Proven | Proven | Yes |
| 6-month momentum return from 6 months to 1 month ago | Proven | Promising | Proven | Yes |
| Near the 52-week high close against the highest close of a year | Proven | Promising | Proven | Yes |
| Profit growth profit growth on the year, newest results | Not proven | Proven | Proven | Yes |
| Results-day move the move on the day after the newest results | Not proven | Proven | Proven | Yes |
| 1-month reversal the last month's fall, as a positive | Not proven | Not proven | Not proven | No |
| Calm low 60-day volatility | Proven | Not proven | Promising | No |
| Earnings yield trailing earnings per share / price | Not proven | Proven | Promising | No |
A factor counts only if it was proven up to 2020 and held up from 2021 (results factors: a stronger test over 24 months or more).
Details for the statistically minded
Each month every factor is set against the next 21 trading days' returns across the companies (rank correlation). A price factor is used only when it showed an edge up to 2020 and the years from 2021 confirmed it; a results factor needs a stronger edge over 24 months at least. Counted here on the years from 2021.
Risk order and rank
Proven The jumpiest companies fell 10 % more often than the calmest (checked on 2021 onwards, after the rule was set): 70 months.
Proven The rank put the next month's returns in the right order (checked on 2021 onwards, factors picked on the years before): 70 months.
Technical signals, over the next month
| Signal | Separate cases | Vs an ordinary day | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Breakdown from a squeeze | 243 | -0.07 % | Not proven |
| Breakout up from a squeeze | 242 | -0.45 % | Went the other way |
| Close back above the 200-day average | 241 | -0.94 % | Went the other way |
| Close below the 200-day average | 241 | -0.06 % | Not proven |
| Death cross | 230 | -0.24 % | Not proven |
| Down-trend gains strength | 245 | +1.16 % | Went the other way |
| Gap down of 3 % or more | 250 | +0.36 % | Not proven |
| Gap up of 3 % or more | 250 | +1.27 % | Promising |
| Golden cross | 226 | -0.32 % | Not proven |
| MACD crosses above its signal line | 249 | -0.11 % | Not proven |
| MACD crosses below its signal line | 249 | +0.33 % | Not proven |
| New 52-week high | 234 | -0.40 % | Not proven |
| New 52-week low | 203 | +0.51 % | Not proven |
| RSI falls into the oversold zone | 244 | +1.01 % | Not proven |
| RSI leaves the overbought zone | 248 | -0.82 % | Not proven |
| RSI leaves the oversold zone | 247 | +0.61 % | Not proven |
| RSI rises into the overbought zone | 247 | -1.25 % | Not proven |
| Up-trend gains strength | 244 | -1.22 % | Went the other way |
| Volume spike on a down day | 249 | +0.21 % | Not proven |
| Volume spike on an up day | 249 | -0.72 % | Went the other way |
What followed each signal across the NIFTY 500 companies outside the NIFTY 50 over the next month, minus what followed an ordinary day of the same month - the figure each result was tested on. A dash: not worked out yet.
Past pattern, not a promise.